The Pros and Cons of Vinyl Siding by siding contractors

THE PROS What are the Upsides to Vinyl Siding compared to Hardie Board, LP Smartside and Steel siding in a climate like Bozeman, Helena, and Great Falls?


What do siding contractors think based on their experience.


Like most siding materials, vinyl sidings are available in good, better and best categories. At America’s Choice we focus on the better and best vinyl sidings so you will know what to look for, and what to expect if you side your home with vinyl siding. 


The first thing that you will notice as you compare different vinyl sidings is the thickness or the weight. Vinyl siding is measured in mils, or a thousandths of an inch. 0.044” is a standard thickness, and your premium vinyl sidings are a little thicker, usually 0.046” Your thinner sidings will tend to sag in the hot Montana sun, and will get brittle in the cold Montana winters. 


Vinyl sidings of the past were known to fade quickly and is some cases unevenly. So you will want to look for a colorfast product. Look for a vinyl siding that has an ASTM rating typically found on the side of the box, or ask us and we can tell you. 


The premium vinyl sidings of today contain titanium dioxide, and it is responsible to inhibit fading. 


Look for a vinyl siding with a deep profile or a deeper wood grain pattern. This will aid in both shading and appearance. Premium grades of vinyl siding are available in a wide range of colors. 


Look for a limited life time warranty. Your typical (cheap) vinyl sidings will carry a 10 to 25 year warranty. Your premium vinyl sidings will be backed by lifetime warranties against manufacturing defects. 


If you are gathering info on other types of sidings you may want to look into Hardie Board or LP Smart Side, or steel.


THE CONS


The Downside to Vinyl Siding compared Hardie board and vinyl siding in climates like Bozeman, Helena and Great falls? What siding contractors know from experience...


Maybe the most significant downside to vinyl siding is our climate here in Montana. It has been said that vinyl siding is a product for homes in a mild climate, not too hot, not too cold. Vinyl sidings tend to get brittle and crack or break in cold subzero temperatures and it get soft and saggy in the heat. 


PRICING 


How Vinyl Siding compares as an investment

compared to Hardie Board and Steel siding in a climate like Bozeman, Helena, ad Great Falls? What do siding contractors think based on their experience. 


.




the types and styles of vinyl siding
the types and styles of vinyl siding

The pros and cons of steel siding

The Pros

 

The Pros of steel siding compared to Hardie Board, LP Smart Side and Vinyl Siding, Steel siding in a climate like Bozeman, Helena, ad Great Falls? What do siding contractors think based on their experience.

One of the advantages of steel siding is low maintenance. Steel will require very little attention especially here in Montana where are severe winters can take their toll on exterior siding. Our extreme weather conditions have very little effect on steel. Steel sidings will not support insects. 

Another advantage to steel is fire resistance. Typically this will translate into lower insurance premiums. 

What are the benefits of steel siding Compared to Vinyl siding, LP Smart Side  and Hardie board in a climate like Bozeman, Helena, ad Great Falls? What do siding contractors think based on their experience.

Along with low maintenance, durability, and fire resistance steel sidings can be very dent-resistant. Most steel sidings are back with limited, life time warranties. These warranties are usually transferrable to a new home owner. 

How does steel siding compare to vinyl siding, LP Smart Side and Hardie Board in climates like Helena, Bozeman and Great Falls as an investment? What siding contractors know from experience...


Siding contractors know that when they install steel they are eliminating the issues that our harsh winters bring. Steel in unaffected by extreme weather and is very low maintenance. 


Again, as with vinyl, look for a product that is fade resistant and color fast. 

Siding contractors in Bozeman, Helena and Great Falls
Siding contractors in Bozeman, Helena and Great Falls

the pros and cons of lp smart side

LP Smart Side, the Pros

 LP Smart Side is the new high-end siding of choice in Montana.


What are the pros of LP Smartside compared to Hardie Board, Vinyl and Steel Sidings in a climate like Bozeman, Helena, ad Great Falls? What do siding contractors think based on their experience.


LP Smart Side is an engineered wood product and it is one of the most durable siding solutions on the market today. It offers superior resistance to rain and snow, wind, hail, mold and insects. It is offered in many different colors and designs. 


Their Lap Siding has a beautiful cedar texture to boost your curb appeal. Also, Shingles and Shakes are available is both staggered and straight edges for a gorgeous textured effect. 

Trim, soffits and fascia are all coordinated to create a premium appearance. It is also available in a vertical application. 


The Cons 

Maintenance and installation issues are the only downside to LP Smart Side. Eventually LP Smart will need to be refreshed with a coat of paint. It will age over time. Installation requires that all cuts that expose the engineered wood need to be primed and painted to eliminate moisture damage. 

Maintanence and installation issues are the only downside to LP Smart Side. Eventually LP Smart will need to be refreshed with a coat of paint. It will age over time. Installation requires that all cuts that expose the engineered wood need to be primed and painted to eliminate moisture damage. 

LP Smart Side will burn if exposed to fire. 

What are the Cons of LP Smartside compared to Hardie Board, Vinyl Siding and Steel siding in a climate like Bozeman, Helena, and Great Falls? What do siding contractors think based on their experience.

When compared to Hardie Board, LP Smart Side is a much lighter product and its hail resistance is better than the fiber cement. 

LP Smart Side is considered up scale. However it is very affordable when compared to other sidings on the market. 

LP Smart Side in Great Falls, MT
LP Smart Side in Great Falls, MT

the pros and cons of hardie board

The Pros


Hardie Board lap siding is a fiber cement and probably one of the most popular siding solutions today. Its Cedarmill has a natural cedar look that can be installed with a color fast texture, or a primed for paint texture. 


How does Hardie Board compare to vinyl siding as an investment in climates like Bozeman Helena and Great Falls. What siding contractors know from experience.


Fiber cement is resistant to insects, weather, water and fire. It may qualify you for a break on your insurance premiums. 


All Hardie Board sidings are backed with a non-prorated, 30 year warranty. The trim products all carry a 15 year warranty. 


What are the Cons of Hardy board compared to vinyl and steel sidings, LP Smart Side in climates like Bozeman, Helena and Great Falls? What siding contractors know from experience. 


The Cons


Hardie Board is heavy and it comes with regular maintenance like cleaning and painting. 


How does Hardie Board compare to vinyl siding as an investment in climates like Bozeman Helena and Great Falls. What siding contractors know from experience.


Hardie Board is a lifetime investment and with the proper care you will have one of the best looking homes on your block. It is one of the most expensive sidings on the market today but for home owners that demand durability it is worth the cost of installing Hardie Board. 


Hardie Board in Great Falls, MT
Hardie Board in Great Falls, MT

Our Citations and Partners

image148
image149
image150
image151